FOR TODAY Guitarist Kicked Out; Band says He Doesn’t “Believe in the Same Jesus”

by | Apr 16, 2015

Lots of drama surrounding For Today these days. You may remember how just a few weeks ago the band’s former guitarist called out frontman Mattie Montgomery for being in a cult; and now the group have kicked out guitarist Samuel Penner, apparently for not sharing the same religious beliefs, among other things.

Penner took to his blog to write a lengthy farewell post, explaining why the band gave him the boot.

Here’s an excerpt,

I was told that I was unequally yoked with the band because of my personal beliefs of how I should live my life after coming to know Jesus. For this reason, the band could no longer support me or walk with me on this path. (To be clear about this, for those who care, my personal belief is simply that a standard of living our lives after salvation has been set by God in the “Old Testament” law. Not for salvation but for living a life in service to God.)

He went on to say,

[I]t was dishonoring that they had found issues with me as a brother in the faith, but instead of pulling me aside personally or communally to talk through these issues, they simply came together without me and decided what would be most beneficial for me and my family.

Then added,

It was expressed by one member that “I don’t believe in the same Jesus or gospel” as the members of the band.

You can read the full post at his personal blog here.

Trap Them Interview with Vocalist Ryan McKenney

  What is the definition of a successful band? A band that graces the covers of mainstream magazines, or is success defined as consistent touring, playing in front of 20 kids per night? Trap Them vocalist Ryan McKenney has little concern for mainstream notoriety...

Bleeding Through Interview on Ryan’s Rock Show

If you’ve been a Ryan’s Rock Show reader for a minute, you may remember the interview I did a while back with Death By Stereo. I got into a pretty long discussion with the dudes about the early Orange County punk scene, and how a small community of kids...

From First To Last Interview – Matt Manning, Blake Steiner – ‘Throne to the Wolves’

It has been quite some time since I last sat down with the From First To Last gentlemen. In fact, my previous interview with the band was about Sonny Moore quitting the group, working with Ross Robinson on “Heroine”, and Wes Borland of Limp Bizkit filling...

Glassjaw Interview: DIY Roots, Frustrations & Creative Freedom

About this interview In a 2009 interview with Ryan Minic of Ryan’s Rock Show, Glassjaw members Daryl Palumbo, Justin Beck, and Manuel Ragoonanan Carrero reflected on their long history, creative struggles, and frustrations with the music industry. They admitted this...