About this interview:
In a 2009 interview with Ryan Minic of Ryan’s Rock Show, Stephen Brodsky, Adam McGrath, and JR Conners of Cave In reflected on their journey from local hardcore shows to major label experiences and their eventual return to their roots. They shared stories from their early days, citing Converge as a major influence and recalling their teenage ambition of simply playing a show with them. As the band gained traction, they found themselves thrust into bigger opportunities, including touring with Foo Fighters and even flying on Dave Grohl’s private jet.
The conversation delved into the band’s transition to a major label with Antenna, a decision that came with high expectations and compromises. They described the pressure from RCA Records to create a more commercial sound, how label executives tried to dictate their single choices, and how their A&R representative quit just as their album was released, leaving them with little industry support. Looking back, they admitted that while it was an eye-opening experience, it wasn’t a path they would choose again.
Brodsky and McGrath discussed their disillusionment with the mainstream music industry, explaining how relentless touring burned them out and led to Cave In disbanding for several years. They emphasized how the industry’s focus on profits over artistic integrity drained their passion, and how reconnecting with independent labels like Hydra Head allowed them to regain creative control.
Reflecting on their reunion, they expressed gratitude for the chance to play music on their own terms again. They discussed their Planets of Old EP, which was recorded live over just two nights, a stark contrast to the months-long, high-budget process of Antenna. They emphasized the raw energy of capturing performances in real-time rather than overproducing tracks in the studio.
Throughout the interview, Cave In remained candid about their ups and downs, their struggle to balance artistry with industry expectations, and their ultimate decision to stay true to their DIY roots.